On March 23, 2021, The Home Small Enterprise, Markets and Infrastructure Subcommittee held a distant listening to titled: “The Interplay Between the Paycheck Safety Program and Federal Procurement Rules: What It Means for Authorities Contractors”. The listening to targeted particularly on the interaction between Paycheck Safety Program (PPP) mortgage cancellation and Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) 31.201-5 “credit”, and the way this interplay impacts federal contractors who carry out value kind contracts. This assembly highlights an space the place entrepreneurs have incomplete instructions at finest. We are going to proceed to watch these points as new steering is launched.

FAR 31.201-5 states that: “The relevant a part of any earnings, rebates, allowance or different credit score referring to any eligible value and obtained by or accruing to the contractor shall be credited to the federal government both as a discount in prices or within the type of reimbursement in money. “This provision applies to: (1) the pricing of negotiated contracts and contract modifications at any time when value evaluation is carried out, (2) the willpower of reimbursable prices underneath contracts reimbursement of prices and the reimbursement a part of the prices of time and materials contracts,1 and (3) negotiating oblique tariffs.2

Thus, insofar because the proceeds of the PPP mortgage are utilized by the contractor to cowl the direct or oblique prices topic to the FAR 31.201-5 (for instance, eligible value reimbursed by the federal government underneath a price reimbursement contract), and the mortgage is subsequently canceled, the federal government is entitled to a credit score. Particularly, the Division of Protection (DoD) clarified that, to the extent that the proceeds from the PPP mortgage have been used to pay for prices in any other case reimbursed underneath a authorities contract and the proceeds from the PPP mortgage have been finally canceled, a credit score is required in accordance with FAR 31.201-5.

On December 20, 2020, the Protection Contracts Audit Company (DCAA) issued recommendation to its statutory auditors, as subsequently revised on January 28, 2021, regarding the processing of the FAR credit score 31.201-5. As a part of these tips, DCAA has issued the next directions:

  • The canceled PPP mortgage quantity will apply as a credit score or money reimbursement in the identical approach that the PPP mortgage proceeds have been utilized by the contractor. If, for instance, the proceeds from the PPP mortgage have been used to pay lease and the lease is included in an oblique value pool, that value pool needs to be credited throughout the interval wherein the PPP mortgage was canceled.
  • Credit score isn’t required for the proceeds of the PPP mortgage used for prices attributable to Agency Worth Contract (FFP). For instance, no credit score is required for canceled PPP mortgage proceeds used to pay workers for work carried out underneath business contracts or FFP contracts not topic to DSC value rules.
  • With respect to ahead pricing, as prices incurred in calendar years 2020 and 2021 are used as a part of the premise for estimating proposals, auditors ought to perceive how these prices incurred have been affected by Coronavirus Help, Aid and Financial Safety (CARES) Act in addition to the impact on future estimates.

The Home subcommittee famous that it had heard small companies advocate for waiving the DSC mortgage clause to cancel PPP loans. Naturally, these small companies have complained that making use of for such credit score is opposite to the intent of the PPP mortgage in that the mortgage isn’t actually canceled if the federal government truly calls for reimbursement of the mortgage by credit. Identifier.

This listening to might have been triggered by the Division of Transportation (DOT) draft tips launched on January 22, 2021. Carlos A. Penin, PE President, CAP Engineering, testified on the listening to that these tips require that the prices be incurred. overheads of a contractor be diminished by the quantity of PPP mortgage cancellations granted to engineering corporations. Mr Penin added {that a} discount within the overhead charge would in flip cut back future billing charges and, for a lot of engineering corporations, lead to a web loss better than the PPP low cost. Robin S. Greenleaf, PE, talking on behalf of the American Council of Engineering Corporations, echoed Mr Penin’s concern, explaining that “[t]The audited oblique value charge is used for an accounting interval of 1 yr, however can also be the speed used during a contract, which is commonly multi-year. Ms. Greenleaf famous that DOT work is often carried out over a number of years, contracts that lock within the billing charge.

In response to considerations raised by small enterprise entrepreneurs, the subcommittee decided that “[a]At a minimal, will probably be necessary to make sure consistency within the software of the credit score clause between the businesses in order that it doesn’t lead to an undue benefit for the federal government and that the well-being of the contractor is protected. . overheads equivalent to the quantity of the PPP mortgage cancellation, and making use of these diminished charges over the time period of a multi-year contract was opposite to the requirement of FAR 31.205-1 that the “relevant half” of a credit score referring to any eligible prices needs to be credited to the federal government.

On March 24, 2021, the day after the Home listening to, the DOT Federal Freeway Administration (FHWA) issued a memorandum concerning “Processing of Paycheck Safety Program Funds for Architectural and Engineering Consulting”. The memorandum acknowledges that the proceeds from the PPP mortgage have been supposed to “allow firms to keep up wage prices, stop workers from shedding their jobs throughout the 2019 coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19), and canopy the overhead prices essential to proceed enterprise operations “. The memorandum, nonetheless, goes on to state that the PPP “was not enacted to supply an financial windfall to the employer (for instance, when prices are reimbursed by the federal authorities underneath a contract financed by the federal authorities). and that the PPP mortgage can also be canceled by the SBA.). ” Identifier. Due to this fact, neither DOT nor DOD tips waived the credit score provision.

The memorandum applies to architectural and engineering providers offered underneath Federal-Help or Federal Lands Freeway (FLH) funded contracts the place the guide seeks partial or full cancellation of the PPP mortgage. The rules acknowledge that these contracts embody a provision prohibiting unauthorized donations to a challenge. Thus, the DOT tips require that consultants search reimbursement from the company for direct challenge prices and supply {that a} guide can’t use the proceeds of the PPP mortgage to pay for direct challenge prices even when the prices don’t. usually are not billed to the federally funded challenge. The DOT tips are as follows:

  • Structure and Engineering (A&E) consultants can’t use the proceeds of the PPP mortgage to pay the direct prices of a contract funded by federal help or by the FLH.
  • A&E Consultants can’t cost for direct prices and use the proceeds of PPP loans to fund direct labor compensation prices and different direct prices spent on federally funded contracts. This apply leads to inappropriate fee for billing to the federal authorities on two events. A guide can use the PPP mortgage as a working capital mortgage to pay the direct prices of a contract, however should submit a well timed reimbursement request to the contracting company and make the suitable and needed changes in its accounting data an as soon as the refund is obtained. .
  • The proceeds of the PPP mortgage can’t be used to pay for the direct prices of the challenge, even when these prices usually are not billed to the federally funded contract. This motion leads to a donation to the challenge, which has not been licensed and conflicts with the phrases and situations of the contract. A&E consultants ought to proceed to allocate and bill direct and oblique prices in accordance with the phrases of the contract.
  • A&E consultants can use the proceeds of the PPP mortgage to pay oblique prices, however an adjustment of the oblique value charge is required in accordance with [FAR 31.201-5].
  • A&E consultants should modify their oblique value charges for canceled PPP funds to be able to present the corresponding credit score to the federal authorities. All oblique value credit needs to be mirrored within the subsequent adjusted oblique value charge. If an A&E guide can apply the suitable credit score for oblique prices on current contracts, the contracting group might authorize the guide to take action.
  • All relevant credit (or mortgage recoveries) needs to be utilized on the premise of an equitable allocation to all beneficiary value targets in accordance with [FAR 31.201-4]. Credit score on the oblique value charge ought to solely be utilized till the credit score is absolutely recovered. If an A&E guide’s oblique value charge changes don’t have an effect on the award or kind of contract (e.g., Agency Fastened Worth or Lump Sum contract), the adjustment of that contract is not going to wouldn’t be needed.

Identifier. at 2 hours.

The DOT FHWA tips permit the guide to make use of the proceeds of the PPP mortgage as a working capital mortgage to pay the direct prices of a contract, however the guide should submit a well timed declare to the company for reimbursement of the prices. direct prices and, after receiving reimbursement from the company. , make the required changes to the accounting data. The guide doesn’t have the choice of utilizing the proceeds of the PPP mortgage to pay the direct prices and never request reimbursement from the company.

DOT FHWA tips require consultants to regulate their oblique value charges to the extent that the proceeds of the canceled PPP mortgage have been used to pay for the oblique prices. Nevertheless, the steering doesn’t require the usage of the diminished oblique charges for the whole lot of a multi-year contract in that they state that the diminished charge for oblique prices ought to solely be utilized till the credit score is absolutely recovered. Thus, the consultants could also be required to repay the PPP mortgage successfully by diminished oblique charges, however they won’t be required to repay the federal government greater than the quantity of the PPP mortgage.

This listening to and the DOT FHWA tips, which seem to have sparked it, are unlikely to be the ultimate say on this matter, as Congress balances the necessities of the FAR credit score provision with the will to supply authorities contractors with the identical. benefit of the PPP low cost than their gross sales. counterparts. We are going to proceed to watch instructions on this space.


1 FAR 31.201-5 doesn’t apply to time and materials contracts the place materials is invoiced on a foundation aside from value.

2 FAR 31.103 (a), (b) (1), (b) (2).

As a result of generality of this replace, the knowledge offered on this doc is probably not relevant in all conditions and shouldn’t be carried out with out particular authorized recommendation primarily based on explicit conditions.

© Morrison & Foerster LLP. All rights reserved

Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.